登陆注册
5416500000106

第106章 Chapter IV(16)

Freedom of opinion is absolutely essential to progress,social as well as intellectual,and therefore thought should be able to play freely upon the sway of irrational custom.The tyranny of the commonplace,of a mental atmosphere which stifles genius and originality,is a danger to social welfare.That Mill held such convictions strongly was the source of his power.That he held to them,even when they condemned some party dogma,was honourable to his sincerity.That he filed to make them into a satisfactory or consistent whole was due to preconceptions imbibed from his teachers.Perhaps it is truer to say that he could not accurately formulate his beliefs in the old dialect than that his beliefs were intrinsically erroneous.

Upon his terms a clear demarcation of the sphere of free action is impossible.Mill,as an 'individualist,'took society to be an 'aggregate'instead of an,organism.'To Mill such phrases as 'organic'savoured of 'mysticism';they treated a class name as meaning something more than the individuals,and therefore meant mere abstractions parading as realities,(60)and encouraged the fallacies current among Intuitionists and Transcendentalists.And yet they point at truths which are anything but mystical.It is a plain fact that society is a complex structure upon which every man is dependent in his whole life;and that he is a product,moulded through and through by instincts inherited or derived from his social position.

Conversely,it is true that the society is throughout dependent upon the character or the convictions and instincts of its constituent members.To overlook the reciprocal action and reaction,and the structure which corresponds to them,is necessarily to make arbitrary and inaccurate assumptions and to regard factors in a single process as independent entities.The tendency of the Utilitarian was to regard society as a number of independent beings,simply bound together by the legal or quasi-legal sanctions.Morality itself was treated as a case of external 'law.'The individual,again,was a bundle of ideas,bound together by 'associations which could be indefinitely modified.'In both cases,the unity was imposed by a force in some sense 'external,'and therefore the whole social structure of individual character became in some sense 'artificial.'It is the acceptance of such assumptions which hinders Mill in his attempt to mark out the individual sphere.

We have seen the difficulties.In morality,it is impossible to divide the 'extra-regarding'from the 'self-regarding'qualities,because morality is a function of the whole character considered as a unit.Mill,therefore,has to concede a considerable sphere to moral pressure.The fact that in positive law it is not only possible but necessary to distinguish 'self-regarding'actions from 'extra-regarding'actions marks the sphere within which legislation can work efficiently.But the same fact proves also that the direct legal coercion is only a subordinate element in the whole social process.Though it is only called into play to suppress certain overt actions,it indirectly affects the whole character:it may help to stimulate all the qualities,'self-regarding'or otherwise,which form a good citizen;and to argue that it should be indifferent to these broader results is to omit a reference to the wider 'utility'which is identical with morality.Mill is thus driven to awkward casuistry by trying to exclude the moral considerations where they are obviously essential,or to admit them under some ingenious pretext.In economic problems the difficulty is more conspicuous;for we have there to do with the whole industrial structure,which is affected throughout by institutions created or confirmed by law.It is,again,impossible to distinguish the spheres of the 'natural'and the 'artificial'--or of individual and state action.The industrial structure is a product of both.

Consider all state action to be bad because 'artificial,'and you are led to such an isolation of the 'individual'as reduces all responsibility to a name for selfishness.You are to teach men to be prudent simply by leaving the imprudent to starvation.Mill,revolted by this consequence,admits that the state must have regard to the injustice for which it is,at least indirectly,responsible.He then inclines to exaggerate the power of the 'artificial'factor because it embodies human 'volition'and leans towards the crude Socialism which assumes that all institutions can be arbitrarily reconstructed by legislative interference.Hence when we come to the political problem,to the organ by which the legal bond is constructed,Mill exaggerates the power of 'making'as contradistinguished from the 'growing.'

He seems to assume that institutions can 'create'the instincts by which they are worked:or to forget that they primarily transmit instead of originating power,though indirectly they foster or hinder the development of certain tendencies.Mill would guard against the abuse of political power by dividing it among the separate individuals.He then perceives that he is only redistributing this tremendous power instead of diminishing its intensity.By isolating the 'individual'he has condemned him to narrow views and petty ideals,but has not prevented him from impressing them upon the mass of homogeneous units.Hence,he is alarmed by the inevitable 'tyranny of the majority.'He has put a tremendous power into the hands of Demos,and can only suggest that it should not be exercised.

It is,if I am right,the acceptance of this antithesis,put absolutely,the 'individual,'as something natural on one side,and law,on the other side,as a bond imposed upon the society,which at every step hampers Mill's statement of any vital truths.

同类推荐
  • 济颠道济禅师语录

    济颠道济禅师语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Aucassin and Nicolete

    Aucassin and Nicolete

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 阿难七梦经

    阿难七梦经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • No Thoroughfare

    No Thoroughfare

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 十门辩惑论

    十门辩惑论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 戊午暑期国文讲义汇刊

    戊午暑期国文讲义汇刊

    本书乃民国七年江苏省立第三师范学校国文讲义之汇编,撰写者分别为无锡钱基博、吴江薛凤昌、吴江沈昌直,时在戊午暑期,意在为初学者习国文辟一从入之门耳,三书于国文奥义、作法、根底各有侧重,惟指示大略,令习者得乎其法,明乎其径,优而游之一也,故名之。
  • 悸九哪里逃

    悸九哪里逃

    霸道如龙的陆御城,温顺如羊的苏悸九在开学的第一天,小羊竟然惹怒霸王龙…他们之间又会擦出怎么的火花呢
  • 神奇宝贝之英雄传

    神奇宝贝之英雄传

    阿尔宙斯的暴走,蕴涵着毁灭力量的石板,继承天神之力的炎枫,是否能阻止世界的毁灭。。。。
  • 新修本草

    新修本草

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 剑与龙之王座

    剑与龙之王座

    剑与火,机械与炼金法阵,金属的魔神降临人世。这是英豪与枭雄之间的百花乱舞。乱世风起,群雄逐鹿,战争的画卷渐渐在两片大陆谱写开来。一场场旷世奇恋,一曲曲战地悲歌,在血肉之躯与钢铁军团的碰撞中,演绎一场宏大的战地史诗。
  • The Virgin of the Sun

    The Virgin of the Sun

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 春天在到来的路上

    春天在到来的路上

    《春天在到来的路上》是日本画家兼诗人竹久梦二创作的童趣小品集,展现出一个诗人和父亲用纯粹的童趣,对少年时代的纯净追忆。书中收录了竹久梦二创作的58篇童趣小品文,以及110余幅手绘儿童画,可以说是国内迄今为止收录竹久梦二儿童文学作品(不包括童谣)最全的中文译本,体现了他在儿童插画、儿童故事创作领域的成就。
  • 六界之校园王者

    六界之校园王者

    王者?社会现实就是这么的残酷,范翔翼感觉到自己被逐渐的埋没,直到有一天,六界闯入了他的生活...考试,作业什么的都是浮云,考个第一吓死你!美女,兄弟身边一大排,有多少是真的?战争,斗智谁能笑到最后?努力,承受,那才是王道!细致入微的格斗描写,场面华丽的六界技能,惊心动魄的校园斗智,场面宏大的万人战争,各种特色的极品美女...谁是强者?谁是王者?敬请期待《六界之校园王者》
  • 爱丽丝漫游奇境记(语文新课标课外读物)

    爱丽丝漫游奇境记(语文新课标课外读物)

    语文新课标指定了中小学生的阅读书目,对阅读的数量、内容、质量以及速度都提出了明确的要求,这对于提高广大学生的阅读写作能力,培养语文素养,促进终身学习等具有深远的意义。
  • 龙牙

    龙牙

    一八七六年,无法无天的淘金者进入战乱不断的美国西部,而对白人充满敌意的印第安人随时准备剥了他们的头皮。劣地黄沙漫天,两个偏执的古生物学家为探寻恐龙化石来到这里。他们彼此欺骗,互拆墙脚,都想赶在对方之前有所发现。不知天高地厚的耶鲁大学学生约翰逊为了一个愚蠢的赌约,误入这场混战。他加入了古生物学家马什的探险队。但多疑的马什怀疑约翰逊是宿敌科普教授派来的密探,把他遗弃在怀俄明的夏延。约翰逊被迫转入科普的阵营后,无意间获得一项惊人的发现。这令他身陷重重危机,腹背受敌。在很难平安离开的死木镇,为了保护自己的发现,约翰逊必须拼死一搏。