登陆注册
5416500000123

第123章 Chapter V(8)

The Utilitarian principle,again,was opposed to the errors most seductive to earlier historians.The classical histories were meant to be works of art.The artistic aim is incompatible with scientific history,so far as it interferes with the primary aim of giving the unadulterated facts.To give a clear,coherent,and distinct narrative of a complex series of events requires,indeed,powers of literary expression even of the highest order.

The artistic purpose must be strictly subordinate rather than absent.A writer must not disguise or embellish or omit with a view to artistic effect of the whole;and must often sacrifice the impressive to the truthful.Sometimes,indeed,the historian must be dull --but that is a condition against which neither Grote nor the Utilitarians generally protested.It had been the aim of a different school to avoid dulness and to rival the Waverley Novels in making past history live.The errors of such men as Thierry and Michelet,or Carlyle,Macaulay and Froude,show the dangers of the method.The severe historian may perhaps forgive them in consideration of the interest which they excited in their studies.May he not also admit that the aim is,in some sort,legitimate?The people,after all,were once alive,and that truth has some bearing upon their history.If imagination means a faculty of generating illusions,as the Utilitarians generally thought,it is no doubt mischievous.But even for the bare purpose of judging evidence and perceiving truth the imagination is essential.The error of transposing modern standards of thought into previous epochs is too obvious to require illustration;but it is really the fault less of an excess than of a defect of imagination.The writer must be able,at every turn,to put himself in the place of his heroes,and of their contemporaries,if he would understand the meaning of their actions,or even judge the weight to be attributed to the evidence.That requires a trained and duly subordinate faculty of imagination.Even for mere annals --simple statements of hard facts --imagination is required,and it is required the more as we endeavour to rise from annals to history,or to make history more than an 'old calendar.'

A sound Utilitarian might be expected to make the proper compromise.No one could be more on his guard against the error of subordinating truth to poetic fancy.But he would not deny the importance of so much imaginative sympathy as is implied in a clear apprehension of the mental and moral condition of past epochs.He might find a sufficient substitute for the dangerous faculty of picturesque imagination in the more sober faculty which Grote possessed --massive common sense;the 'knowledge of human nature,'as it is called,which corresponds not to poetic imagination or to a set of established formulae,but to the practical insight acquired by intimate acquaintance with actual affairs.If Grote was able to rival or to surpass German professors on their own ground,it was because his want of some of their special training was more than counterbalanced by his experience of business and public life.In Threadneedle Street and at Westminster he had acquired an instinctive perception which served him in describing the political and economical conditions of Athenian life.When joined with an ardour for research that power gave a value to his judgments of fact which enabled him to write a model history.

The 'graphic'or 'artistic'type of history may be objectionable;is not the philosophical worse?Nothing distorts facts so much as theory;and a scientific historian should be on his guard against the philosopher of all men.But how to draw the line?Stick to bare fact and you can only write annals.History proper begins as you introduce causation,and the mere series is transformed into a process.It is impossible to get a bare fact without some admixture of theory.The Utilitarian principle,again,suggests the right aim.It excludes the mischievous didacticism of older historians.The question of fact must everywhere precede the question of right.In politics,economics and ethics Bentham and Malthus and the Mills had in various relations applied the principle which applies equally to history,The historian may adopt Spinoza's great saying.His business is to understand,not to approve or denounce.A historian treats of some great event such as the French revolution.His one legitimate and dominant purpose should be to explain its causes,and he should inquire with absolute impartiality how it came to pass,not whether it was right or wrong.The old method of writing history attributed events to individuals,and consistently applied a moral estimate.If the action of this or that man,Mirabeau or Robespierre,was the ultimate cause of the events,we may ask whether the action was good or bad,and infer that the event ought or ought not to have happened.The scientific view fixes attention simply On the causes.What were the conditions which determined the event?We must inquire as impartially as a pathologist examining the causes of a disease.

同类推荐
  • Essays and Tales

    Essays and Tales

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 画墁集

    画墁集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 神仙感遇传

    神仙感遇传

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 岳阳风土记

    岳阳风土记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 龙川略志

    龙川略志

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 孕产妇菜谱

    孕产妇菜谱

    本书主要讲述孕妇在产前、产中及产后坐月子时所需的各种营养搭配的各种菜谱。
  • 流离的萤火爱情

    流离的萤火爱情

    抬头看到的就是他那双孤傲的眼睛,散发着无数的寒气,让人不寒而栗,那张脸简直无懈可击,与哥哥相比似乎更胜一筹,但是他满脸的高傲和不屑,瞬间拒人于千里之外。那个冰山男依旧惜字如金,没有表情,我开始有些怀疑,老哥是不是认错人啦?呼呼,不理他们啦,走咯“答应我一个要求!”说得这么爽快?是早有预谋吗?可是不应该,总不至于他是策划者吧“要求?行,但是你不可以说…”委屈啊,莫名其妙地要答应冰山男一个要求。“不管如何,你都要信我!”那是你对我的乞求吗?一次次的错过,一次次的误会,他们之间是否经得起时间的考验?可爱善良的韩雪柔能够等到幸福钟声响起吗?面对昔日的男友、今时的未婚夫,她该如何抉择?求收藏,求推荐,求订阅,嘻嘻,我会再接再厉的~~~推荐——http://m.pgsk.com/a/450433/《邪魅总裁:女人,乖乖躺着!》推荐新作温馨治愈系列:听说,爱情回来过。http://m.pgsk.com/a/702512/
  • 田园巧妇

    田园巧妇

    貌似七仙女,赛过西施,气死貂蝉,羞死杨贵妃,窘坏了林黛玉的一位农大高才生,辣辣的小女子,在某个农研所极度地不受待见,被驱赶着开了一辆即将报废的大卡车,给农业大户送种子。遭逢意外来到一个未知的世界,顶替了一个受气媳妇,捡了一个被人遗弃的孤儿,成了被虐对象。有幸得到了一个修真空间,有了良田,有了饱饭充饥,有动物世界援助收拾恶人。现实可比想的美,飘飘然到了一个没人知道的世界,理想实现的她大喜过望,美夫围着转,孝子绕膝前,馋得嫦娥下了凡,织女气得拆鹊桥,七仙女要把董郎换,人间天上都羡慕。这样的生活都想要,唯有她一个人能得到。
  • 叶成玉心

    叶成玉心

    他,来自梵天的神秘来客。她,某私立高中的学霸少女。叶欣:“交给警察蜀黍还是带回家先养着?”叶恒:“不删我号,你说咋办就咋办。”玉容:“我会法术会做饭分身术学习超高效,求收留。”叶欣:“那先收着。”同样来自梵天的邪灵,也随之而至,两个世界岌岌可危,一切的源头是魔尊?又或是........清甜,微虐,玄幻,推理,纯属原创,拒绝抄袭,如有转载,请注明出处。你的收藏和推荐,还有绝佳演员郑业成都是我写作的动力!另有支线《长笙集》写的是《叶成玉心》中其他角色的故事,也很有趣~求收藏送豆
  • 西戎小说散文集(山药蛋派经典文库)

    西戎小说散文集(山药蛋派经典文库)

    《西戎小说散文集》精选他的小说和散文若干篇。他的作品重点在于表现由私有制向集体所有制过渡中,农民与基层干部在思想观念、意识作风和道德风尚方面发生的变化和旧思想、旧习惯的克服过程。
  • 中俄伊犁交涉始末

    中俄伊犁交涉始末

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 破儿修仙记

    破儿修仙记

    亦人亦鬼,亦正亦邪。苦乐情仇,甘怡自知。江湖险恶,仙路荆棘。未失本心,终成大道!
  • 那些死亡教我如何活

    那些死亡教我如何活

    特殊清扫,清扫的不只是普通的垃圾,而是一个人留在世界上最后的痕迹。从事特殊清扫20年,无数次进出各类死亡现场,见过形形色色不同的人,在生与死的边缘,他选择用笔记录下自己所经历和思考的一切。有善终的老人,葬礼上全无悲哀肃穆的气氛;有因病而亡的运动少年,戴着奖牌走完了在人世的最后一程;有自我了结的中年人,在墙壁的月历上留下奋斗的记号;也有“孤独死”的人,却有一生的挚友帮其善后……对死者来说,人世的变幻无常在死亡的那一刻已然定格。可是对生者而言,关于生与死的思考却永远不会停止。什么是生?什么是死?生命中什么最值得珍惜?站在十字路口,什么才是正确的选择?这些问题,恐怕思索一生也未必能得出一个明确的答案。不知死,焉知生?只有在死亡面前,生命才能凸显其分量;也只有在死亡面前,人生中最弥足珍贵的东西才会浮现。跟随特扫队长进入25个房间,旁观25个人的生命故事,或许我们对于生和死,会有不一样的思考。
  • 星爆

    星爆

    小男孩:爷爷,现在会有外星人来吗?爷爷:傻孩子,外星人的小朋友也要上学的,他们现在都在睡觉了。小男孩:那我也睡觉了,明天比外星人的小朋友还要早到幼儿园。
  • 柒月漠路如顾

    柒月漠路如顾

    。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。