登陆注册
5416500000152

第152章 Chapter VI(16)

The schemes of Free Will and Fatalism,says Hamilton,(105)are 'theoretically balanced,'though the fatalist inconceivability is the 'less obtrusive';but 'practically'we must accept free-will on penalty of admitting the moral law to be 'a mendacious imperative.'That is,right and wrong become meaningless unless you accept one of two equally inconceivable doctrines.So Mansel declares freewill to be 'certain in fact'though 'inexplicable in theory.'(106)Why 'certain,'if,as he also declares,it is part of the 'fundamental mystery'of the coexistence of the Finite and the Infinite?(107)According to Mansel,again,the denial that an infinite Being exists,is simply the acceptance of one of two 'equally inconceivable alternatives.'(108)It is,he declares,'our duty'to think of God as 'personal'and to believe that he is 'infinite.'(109)It is a duty,then,to accept as a certainty what reason declares to be only one of two equally probable alternatives.

The general attitude is familiar enough.Pascal has put it in his famous 'wager.'Believe a thing because it is impossible.You must back one side;and reason is too imbecile to settle which.

Then give up reasoning.The argument is persuasive if not logically convincing.Hamilton was too much of a philosopher and a rationalist to accept it in that form.His application remained ambiguous.Probably he would have approved a rather vague theism,which might be interpreted in terms of many religious creeds.

Mansel,unluckily,had to get from his philosophy to the position of strict Anglican orthodoxy;from the contradictory inconceivables to the Thirty-nine Articles.His method of performing this feat has little interest now;but I must notice it enough to show the relation to Mill.

VI.REVEALED RELIGION

How is this Infinite and Absolute Being to be brought into any relation whatever with facts?How,by accepting one of two equally inconceivable alternatives,can we throw any light upon the truth of a historical statement?Mansel protests that he is not arguing as to the truth of any particular revelation.Though he is not bound to prove the truth of the Christian revelation,he is clearly bound to show that a revelation is probable,and to suggest the criterions by which its reality must be tested.Areligion,as Kant had said,could not be true which conflicted with morality.(110)If morality binds me to be merciful,and a god orders me to be cruel,he cannot be the true God.The deist Tindal had argued long ago that Joshua could not be justified by a divine command in exterminating the Canaanites.(111)In answering this difficulty,Mansel hit upon the unlucky phrase 'Moral Miracles.'(112)A 'moral miracle,'a conversion of a bad act into a good one,was,he admitted,not the kind of experiment to be used too often.Every scoundrel can work 'miracles'of that kind.He can break the divine law though he cannot break the 'law of nature.'How are we to know that in a given case the divine law has been suspended by the supreme ruler and not really broken by the wicked subject?By what logical feat can we show the identity of Jehovah with the Absolute and Infinite?The deity of joshua was frankly anthropomorphic:the (generally)invisible deity of a tribe.We can judge of his character as we can judge of the character of joshua himself,or of the character of Baal,or Moloch,or Zeus.If we argue that all the deities represent an imperfect feeling after a supreme Being,our judgment would not be affected.The deity would still be imperfect.The commands obeyed were still cruel and immoral,as conceived at the time.To argue that they were good because somehow or other Jehovah was the Inconceivable seems to be too obvious a fallacy even for a Bampton Lecturer.Mansel denounces the 'morbid horror of what they (philosophers)are pleased to call Anthropomorphism.'

'Fools'to dream that man can escape from himself,that human reason can draw aught but a human portrait of God.'(113)They really argue that the portrait has at any rate very ugly features,and doubt whether it is possible to draw any portrait whatever of the Inconceivable.

Mansel makes play with this 'antinomy.'The God of his philosophy is too inconceivable to be a moral lawgiver.But,says Mansel,he is also jehovah.Jehovah,it is replied,is immoral.

But,says Mansel,he is also the Inconceivable.This singular mode of eluding difficulties can of course be expressed in edifying language.The 'caviller,'for example,had objected to 'vicarious punishment.'Mansel says(114)that this supposes that nothing can be compatible 'with the boundless goodness of God,which is incompatible with the little goodness of which man may be conscious in himself.'The ingenious argument,in spite of this way of putting it,excited Mill's very justifiable wrath.

同类推荐
  • The Garotters

    The Garotters

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 无量寿经义记

    无量寿经义记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 修禅要诀

    修禅要诀

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 寓圃杂记

    寓圃杂记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • INTRODUCTION to

    INTRODUCTION to

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 快穿之门的打开方式

    快穿之门的打开方式

    岳牙儿万万没有想到,一向手黑的她,竟然会在神之传说的游戏里抽到一个系统,最重要的是,系统附送的新手礼包里有一扇快穿之门……蓝而,本以为是开启愉快的金手指改变别人人生的快(玩)穿(疯)征程,可是最后岳牙儿却发现,她以玩票性质所改变的,竟然也都是她自己的人生……
  • 妃常帝盗

    妃常帝盗

    身为资深老中医的她,有着举世无双的高明医术,她却一直都那月黑风高夜里的绝世神偷,一次意外间穿越竟成了自尽的嫔妃,被连棺材带人一并都献给了帝王,再次苏醒,她已锋芒毕露,惊艳绝尘。“爱妃,朕还是发现自己无法忘却所有。”某女子淡定从容的道:“好马不吃回头草,更何况如今的我有了更好的马。”远处有一男子愤恨之间捏碎了指尖的棋子,眉心狂跳,“本王竟是马?”
  • 我只棕意你

    我只棕意你

    路小姐第一次见到穆三爷,便有了收下这男人的心思。于是在接下来的日子里,穷的只剩钱的路小姐开始了她的漫漫追夫路,各种巧合套路往三爷身上撞,却不想在三爷心中留下一个“女流氓”的称号。*某日,路小姐脱下高跟鞋砸向办公室里的男人:“欲擒故纵是吧?去你大爷的!老子不追了!”一天,两天,三天……路小姐怎么还没有来烦他?穆三爷急了。后来,有记者采访的时候问起:“穆先生有没有特别喜欢的一句话?”穆三爷看眼后台,眉眼含笑:“路漫漫。”
  • 法师雷亚

    法师雷亚

    死亡的气息再次弥漫,腐烂与枯骨肆虐。金色的眼瞳高仰星宇,魔法之光璀璨!少年法师高举魔法之理念,行走于魔法之路,死亡扫去。而阴影之中,一缕黑暗降临,腐蚀大地……
  • 斗之巅

    斗之巅

    新书《我的杂货店很厉害》 斗气江湖,群侠并起。一个身背五尺长剑的青年,站在悬崖上。天空电闪雷鸣,“你难道就不怕,天地惩罚吗?”“怕”少年面色不变,“但是十三却不得不去,与天斗,与地争。”——————————————————群{327373686}
  • 梦不曾消失

    梦不曾消失

    他们是相爱的啊!到底是什么把他们给分开的呢?他们还会在一起吗?他们的爱情还会持续下去吗?也许会,但是阻碍着他们爱情的东西太多了,想要在一起太难了,那么,怎么办呢?牛郎和织女每年见一次面感情还那么好,他们天天见面感情却无人知晓。不过,女主角是不会放弃的!
  • 宰下不约

    宰下不约

    【主宰帝尊】,书名改不了了!啧啧啧。远古万界被打爆,而现世地球是其中一片核心地带形成,后来因为特殊原因(修真界的微信拍卖群为引子),猪脚步越和宇宙中远古界的修真文明联系上。因为鸿蒙无字天书,激活了地球的灵气恢复,天道规则异变。再加上猪脚的父母因为掌握着某件核心之物,而被地球修真界的宗门,放逐到黄泉界,其中甚至牵扯到远古十二祖巫。三皇,人皇伏羲传承现世。带着由三清道祖,女娲娘娘,三皇五帝等代表人族一方的万经阁同时出现……而黑暗位面的诸王,冥王,撒坦,阎王,死神等也在蠢蠢欲动。甚至异世界宇宙大恐怖也显化冰山一角。
  • 南宫先生,别傲娇!

    南宫先生,别傲娇!

    一场五百万的交易,她被迫嫁入第一豪门,沦为食物链最底端的小白兔。住狗屋,佣人欺负,丈夫羞辱,最可怕的是……困境成就了她的野心,屈辱磨练了她的意志。她忍辱负重,步步为营,成为豪门女继承者。小白兔逆袭为大灰狼的历史,从来不靠男人,靠自己。
  • 鹿鼎记(第二卷)(纯文字新修版)

    鹿鼎记(第二卷)(纯文字新修版)

    这是金庸先生最后一部武侠小说,也是登峰造极之作!小说讲的是一个从小在扬州妓院长大的小孩韦小宝,他以不会任何武功之姿态闯江湖各大帮会、周旋皇帝朝臣之间并奉旨远征云南、俄罗斯之故事,书中充满精彩绝倒的对白及逆思考的事件!金庸先生将韦小宝的个人经历与历史密密切合,大玩历史哈哈镜的手法,令人赞叹,几乎信以为真,而小宝的做人方法及毫不留情的揭出人生各阶层黑暗面这种做法,使得这部书成了不是武侠小说的武侠小说,到了无剑胜有剑的境地。韦小宝是个最最普通的人,好像也就是在你我身边的那些人一样。
  • 交换秘密

    交换秘密

    他是回不去的过往,他是未知的现在,而他却是无法触及的未来。每个人都是加害者也是受害者,每个人都有自己的秘密,所有的事你猜得到开头却想不到结局……