登陆注册
5416500000173

第173章 Chapter VI(37)

Acceptance of the intuitions implies acceptance of all legitimate deductions.But this position is more fully 'drawn out'(in his favourite phrase)by Newman.It runs through a whole series of the writings in which the delicacy and subtlety of his style are most fully displayed,(242)and the difficulty of the position most fully exhibited.Chillingworth had stated the Protestant argument.To admit the infallibility of the Church,he had said,takes the individual no further,unless he is infallibly certain of the infallibility.To this Newman replies(243)that I may be certain without claiming infallibility.Certainty that two and two make four is quite consistent with a power of mathematical blundering.Perhaps it should rather be said that,if there be necessary truths,every one must,within their sphere,be infallible.But no one asserts that the infallibility of the Church is a necessary truth.If real,it is a concrete fact to be proved by appropriate evidence.After exhausting your eloquence in proving the fallibility,and indeed the inevitably sceptical result of 'private judgment,'you are bound to show how,in this case,the individual can attain certitude.The judgment that 'the Church is infallible'has been disputed by reasonable people.How are we to show that,in this case,their doubts are unreasonable,if not wicked?Why do not the proofs of the weakness of private judgment apply to this as to every other judgment?Have you not really cut away the foundation on which sooner or later your argument must be based?Yet certitude is made out to be a moral duty even for the average believer.

The theory is most explicitly worked out in the Grammar of Assent.Newman exerts all his skill in expounding a very sound doctrine.As a matter of fact,we form innumerable judgments by what he calls the 'illative sense';that is to say,not by formal argument,but by a complex system of 'implicit'reasonings.

'Logic,'as he says,'does not really prove.It enables us to join issue with others.it verifies negatively';and for 'genuine proof in concrete matter we require an organism more delicate,versatile,and elastic,than verbal argumentation.'(244)Logic is a chain which 'hangs loose at both ends,'(245)for the first principles must be assumed,and the abstract concept never fits the actual complexity of concrete fact.By the 'illative sense,'again,we reach innumerable truths.We hold that England is an island,or that the man whom we see is our brother,with a faith indistinguishable from absolute conviction.We go further;we believe that a friend is honest,or,say,that Caesar crossed the Rubicon,without admitting the slightest scruple of doubt.All knowledge whatever of fact plainly implies something different from formal logic;and,so far,the only question seems to be why so palpable a truth needs so elaborate and graceful an exposition.The answer is indicated by the polemic against Locke.Locke had proposed,as a test of a love of truth,the refusal to hold any proposition,with a greater assurance than the proofs it is built on will warrant.'(246)The statement seems to be not only unassailable but in conformity with Newman's doctrine.Should we believe England to be an island?When Julius Caesar landed,it was not proved;and he would have been wrong to be certain.When did it become right to be certain?Surely at whatever moment it was adequately proved.It is never so proved that to deny it would be self-contradictory,but by this time it is as much proved as any fact can be proved.Locke would simply justify himself by saying that in this case our 'assurance'does not exceed the 'proofs on which it is built.'The approximation to demonstration is indefinitely close,though never absolute,and the difference becomes too small to be perceptible.A difficulty emerges only if we at once admit the rightness of belief and deny the sufficiency of the evidence.

Newman,having shown that we believe in concrete truths not proved by abstract logic,argues that we also assume many truths not proved even by sufficient empirical evidence.We have what Locke called a 'surplusage of assurance.'The fact,again,is undeniable.We believe implicitly in countless things upon insufficient evidence.This,as Locke would add,is one main explanation of the prevalence of error,and also a proof that error may be innocent.It is a duty to be candid;it cannot be a duty to be right.We must listen to reason;but the effect of reasoning must depend upon the constitution of our minds,and the various beliefs with which they are already stored.Now to Newman this doctrine always seems to be sceptical.It amounts to the 'liberalising'view that all creeds are equally good if only they be equally sincere.Hence he lays stress upon the doctrine that 'assent'is a volitional as well as an 'intellectual act.'It is our duty to obey the reason;and when the 'illative sense'declares the truth of a proposition,we are bound to an 'active recognition'of the truth.(247)Locke,on the contrary,holds that if we listen to reason,the assent follows automatically by a non-voluntary act.

On Newman's showing,an element of volition intrudes into logic.Belief belongs to action as well as to pure speculation.

'To act you must assume,'he says,'and that assumption is faith.'(248)If acting upon an hypothesis is the same thing as believing the truth to be demonstrated,this leads to a singular result.A judge,says Newman,acts upon the assumption that a criminal's guilt is proved.(249)Yet,as it is never mathematically demonstrated,he has a 'surplusage of assurance.'

同类推荐
  • 庐陵官下记

    庐陵官下记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 华严一乘成佛妙义

    华严一乘成佛妙义

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太清金液神丹经

    太清金液神丹经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 西游录注

    西游录注

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 戴东原先生轶事

    戴东原先生轶事

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 彪悍武皇

    彪悍武皇

    被石头砸中,不是变白痴就是成牛人。被鬼怪附身,不是变神经病就是变神一样的人。陈旦不仅被石头砸中,还被神魔附身!不过,从此,他过上了非常扯蛋的人生……
  • 容止

    容止

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 追妻无门:女boss不好惹

    追妻无门:女boss不好惹

    青涩蜕变,如今她是能独当一面的女boss,爱了冷泽聿七年,也同样花了七年时间去忘记他。以为是陌路,他突然向他表白,扬言要娶她,她只当他是脑子抽风,他的殷勤她也全都无视。他帮她查她父母的死因,赶走身边情敌,解释当初拒绝她的告别,和故意对她冷漠都是无奈之举。突然爆出她父母的死居然和冷家有丝毫联系,还莫名跳出个公爵未婚夫,扬言要与她履行婚约。峰回路转,破镜还能重圆吗? PS:我又开新文了,每逢假期必书荒,新文《有你的世界遇到爱》,喜欢我的文的朋友可以来看看,这是重生类现言,对这个题材感兴趣的一定要收藏起来。
  • 英雄联盟大龙在洪荒

    英雄联盟大龙在洪荒

    卧槽。我居然成为大龙了?而且还TM穿越到了洪荒!幸好,老子随身带着英雄联盟的系统。小心点别惹我,女娲是我师傅。虽然我一直暗恋她……人族是谁创造的?别问我,我只是插了插手,成为了人族守护而已……盖伦是上单大混子?不不不,他只是我的手下战将而已。还有阿狸,不要每天没事勾引老子,想把老子榨干吗?大龙群628152750
  • 大忏悔文略解

    大忏悔文略解

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 夜泊秦淮河

    夜泊秦淮河

    5岁那年,”别哭了,我给你买糖吃好不好“14岁那年,”别哭了,带你去吃炸酱面“24岁那年,他做了一碗炸酱面一直放到天明也没人吃了
  • 相思引之曾相忘

    相思引之曾相忘

    她本是现代一名中医,一朝穿越,成为护国公府嫡小姐,因父母之仇不卧闺阁,投身江湖,与丐帮联手建立天下第一阁只为调查当年之事。他是南楚五皇子,亦是皇室中可有可无的存在,可谁能想到多年后,这位默默无闻的五皇子不仅继承了南楚江山更是一统华夏大陆,其才华、其谋略、其心性更是令人叹为观止。阴差阳错下,她身中相思引,相思若入骨便再难相解,且看她与他如何如何巧妙化解相思引,守住这一世繁华。(本文纯属虚构)
  • 世界经典神话故事全集:万物有灵的故事

    世界经典神话故事全集:万物有灵的故事

    我们编辑的这套《世界经典神话故事全集》包括《开天辟地的故事》、《神迹仙踪的故事》、《妖魔鬼怪的故事》、《鱼龙精灵的故事》、《荒诞不经的故事》、《奇异自然的故事》、《万物有灵的故事》、《鸟兽灵异的故事》、《英雄传说的故事》和《风俗源流的故事》10册,内容囊括了古今中外著名神话故事数百篇,既有一定的代表性,又有一定的普遍性,非常适合青少年学习和收藏。
  • 中国的房价问题

    中国的房价问题

    住房是每个人的基本需求,房价居高不下,何时能降?保障房、高首付、限购能否拉住房价这匹野马?房价究竟与那些经济因素息息相关?
  • 追妻无门:女boss不好惹

    追妻无门:女boss不好惹

    青涩蜕变,如今她是能独当一面的女boss,爱了冷泽聿七年,也同样花了七年时间去忘记他。以为是陌路,他突然向他表白,扬言要娶她,她只当他是脑子抽风,他的殷勤她也全都无视。他帮她查她父母的死因,赶走身边情敌,解释当初拒绝她的告别,和故意对她冷漠都是无奈之举。突然爆出她父母的死居然和冷家有丝毫联系,还莫名跳出个公爵未婚夫,扬言要与她履行婚约。峰回路转,破镜还能重圆吗? PS:我又开新文了,每逢假期必书荒,新文《有你的世界遇到爱》,喜欢我的文的朋友可以来看看,这是重生类现言,对这个题材感兴趣的一定要收藏起来。