登陆注册
5416500000086

第86章 Chapter III(27)

This,says Mill following Malthus,would be fatal,because the individual would have no motive to support himself.He must only have such a right as implies personal responsibility.But then,as facts also show,many individuals may be unable to support themselves even if they wish it,and their responsibility becomes a mockery.If we enforce duties on all,must we not make the duty possible?Must not every one be so trained and so placed that work will be sure of reward?There is the problem,which he sees and feels,though his answer seems to imply a doubtful shifting between antagonistic theories.

VIII.LOGICAL METHOD

I must glance finally at the relation of Mill's method to his general principles.In an early essay (162)he declares that the method must be 'a priori,'that is,as he explains,'reasoning from an assumed hypothesis.'(163)In the Logic it is treated as a case of the 'direct deductive method.'This involves an important point in his system.He had derived from Comte,as he tells us,(164)only one 'leading conception'of a purely logical kind,the conception,namely,of the 'historical'or 'inverse deductive method.'This method,implied in Comte's sociology,starts,as Mill says,from the 'collation of specific experience.'Now Mill agrees that this 'historical'method was appropriate to sociology in general.He agrees,too,with Comte that it was not the method used by economists.But,whereas Comte had inferred that political economy must for that reason be a sham science,(165)Mill holds that economists were justified in using a different method.Comte,he thought,had failed to see that in certain cases the method of 'direct deduction'was applicable to sociological inquiry.One such case,though he will not undertake to decide what other instances there may be,is political economy.(166)He decides that the difficulties,regarded by Comte as insuperable,may be overcome.His early account is still valid;and he therefore explicitly rejects the 'historical'method.

I confess that the use of these technical phrases appears to me to be rather magniloquent,and to lead to some confusion.

Setting them aside,Mill's view may be briefly stated.He argues,in the first place,that we cannot apply the ordinary method of experiment to economic problems.To settle by experience whether protection was good or bad,we should have to find two nations agreeing in everything except their tariffs;and that,of course,if not impossible,is exceedingly difficult.(167)It follows that if there be a true science of political economy,it must have a different method.We might indeed adopt Comte's answer:

'There is no such science';a view for which there is much to be said.Mill,however,being confident that the science existed had to justify its methods.Political economy,he says,considers man solely as a wealth-desiring being;it predicts the 'phenomena of the social state'which take place in consequence;and makes abstraction of every other motive except the laziness or the desire of present enjoyment which 'antagonise'the desire of wealth.Hence it deduces various laws,though,as a fact,there is scarcely any action of a man's life in which other desires are not operative.Political economy still holds true wherever the desire of wealth is the main end.'Other cases may be regarded as affected by disturbing causes'--comparable,of course,to the inevitable 'friction'--and it is only on account of them that we have an 'element of uncertainty'in political economy.

Otherwise it is a demonstrable science,presupposing an 'arbitrary definition'of a man as geometry presupposes an 'arbitrary definition 'of a straight line.'(168)The relation of this doctrine to Mill's general views on logic is clear,but suggests some obvious criticisms.'Desire for wealth,'for example,is not a simple but a highly complex desire,involving in different ways every human passion.(169)To argue from it,as though its definition were as unequivocal as that of a straight line,is at least audacious.Mill,no doubt,means to express an undeniable truth.Industry,in general,implies desire for wealth,and the whole mechanism supposes that men prefer a guinea to a pound.The fact is clear enough,and if proof be required can be proved by observation.We must again admit that whatever psychological theorem is implied in the fact must be assumed as true.But it does not follow that because we assume the 'desire for wealth'we can deduce the phenomena from that assumption.That inference would confound different things.

If we were accounting for the actions of an individual,we might adopt the method.In some actions a man is guided by love of money,and in others by love of his neighbour.We may 'deduce'his action in his counting-house from his love of money,and consider an occasional fit of benevolence as a mere 'disturbing cause'to be neglected in general or treated as mere 'friction.'

A similar principle might be applied to political economy if we could regard it as the theory of particular classes of actions.

But we have to consider other circumstances to reach any general and tenable theory.We have to consider the whole social structure,the existence of a market and all that it implies,and the division of society into classes and their complex relations:

同类推荐
  • 四溟诗话

    四溟诗话

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 樵香小记

    樵香小记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛说普贤曼拏罗经

    佛说普贤曼拏罗经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 汤头歌诀

    汤头歌诀

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 越史略

    越史略

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 女子本不弱

    女子本不弱

    你说女子本弱,她偏说女子本不弱。你说一介女流,她偏说一介女强流。没有那公主命,哪来那么多公主病。
  • 爱情来过,就不曾离开

    爱情来过,就不曾离开

    卫晓茗以为,爱情,随着她的不告而别,就此离开。可是,萧琰给她的爱情,从不曾离开。
  • 微忧校园印记

    微忧校园印记

    这是一群失落的演奏家,性格迥然但却都乐观充满爱心,并勇于挑战自己命运。生命的际遇让他们像闯进黑暗里的阳光一样进入彼此的视线,编织了整个高中时代最绚烂的生活。但是并不是所有的际遇都如童话般美好,命运之轮把魔鬼撒旦带到大家面前,谁也不知道,他们所有甜蜜的幸福是否会在这个初冬被瞬间抽离……
  • 赤岸:邓小平在晋冀鲁豫

    赤岸:邓小平在晋冀鲁豫

    赤岸是一个小山村的名字。她位于晋冀豫三省交界处太行山脉深深的皱褶里,像蜂巢一样,简单又丰富,默默地悬挂在高高的崖壁上,浸润着风雨,黏附着阳光。小村的脚下有一条河,叫漳河。漳河浩浩而下,哗哗作响,喧响在历史里,流淌在《诗经》里,于是,就有了采桑人杨柳依依的柔媚,就有了楚霸王破釜沉舟的豪壮。漳河在历史上一直是一条大河,她和黄河一起,哺育了广袤的中原文化。
  • 女扮男装:重生妖姬宿世恋

    女扮男装:重生妖姬宿世恋

    红牌杀手一枚,本来钱途无量的她居然穿越到古代!这个穿越游戏实在也太悲催了点,差点一穿越就被人瞬间秒杀。与后妈斗智斗勇,周旋两个美男子之间。失忆,没关系。一大波笨蛋来袭,不要担心!越来越多的神秘人出现,助她一臂之力。且看她如何摆脱这个巨大的阴谋,与最爱的男人仗剑江湖。
  • 吹不灭的夏日烛火

    吹不灭的夏日烛火

    HE,那年风正好,我们刚好相识于夏天。你说你喜欢上了夏天,我吹着风,笑眯了眼。
  • 给人生加点淡定

    给人生加点淡定

    文成蹊编著的《给人生加点淡定》讲述了淡定不是平庸,它是一种生活态度,一种人生境界,是智慧的不争,是宠辱不惊,是对简单生活的一种追求。守住属于自己的一份平淡的生活,就能够成为一个幸福的人。《给人生加点淡定》在告诉人们淡定对人生的重要意义的同时还告诉人们如何才能拥有淡定的人生,从而使得人们能够在生活和工作中保持平和的心情和积极的状态,进而收获幸福而成功的人生。
  • 快穿攻略:病娇大佬,别黑化!

    快穿攻略:病娇大佬,别黑化!

    (1v1双处主甜,男强女强,前期会互掐,后期互宠)这是一个活太久爱搞事的大佬,所引发的一系列故事。洛殊:我只是个爱交朋友,爱聊天的大美人而已,为什么要如此对我!仙界众人:……为什么你心里没点ABC数吗?洛殊:……我们还是看看这本黄历来冷静一下吧。别问,问就是报应。(全文精修中。)
  • 我和美女总裁老婆

    我和美女总裁老婆

    【都市武侠、热血武林。】他,是超级高手,因接受一场传承,导致体质异变,生命受到危机,为延续生命,王者归来……
  • 锦鲤农女软萌甜

    锦鲤农女软萌甜

    “趴下!”“你要对我干什么?!”唐稣攥紧了衣裳。“挨板子!”某男挑眉。穿越成农女,守着二亩薄田,养一二三四五张嘴,极品亲戚虎视眈眈,唐稣的内心是崩溃的,最最可怕的是还得时常被人按在地上打板子,关在屋里亲自授课……唐稣内流满面,我还是个宝宝啊!!……架空,欢脱小甜文。高冷面瘫禁欲系小哥哥VS自带外挂的美貌小姐姐,欢迎入坑。