登陆注册
5416500000098

第98章 Chapter IV(8)

Mill's(24)lamentation over the pettiness of modern English statesmen is familiar.What is really implied?England,as Mill the democrat would have said,was once a country of castes:the priest,the noble,the merchant,the peasant,represented distinct types.Each class was bound by an unalterable custom and conforms to inherited traditions;each,again,discharged some simple or general function now distributed among many minor classes.In later phrase,modern England has been made by processes of 'differentiation'and 'integration.'The old class lines have disappeared,the barriers of custom have been broken down,the old functions have been specialised,and instead of independent individual action,the whole system of life depends upon the elaborate and indefinitely ramified systems of co-operation,deliberate or unconscious.The obvious result is a growth of organic unity,accompanied by an equal development of diversity.Each unit can be assigned to a more special function,because other functions are assigned to co-operating units,and greater mutual dependence is implied in the greater variety of careers and activities.In his democratic phase,Mill blesses this process altogether;he approves the destruction of privilege and caste distinctions;he approves the 'division of labour,'the increased diversity of occupation,and the consequent growth of co-operation;he desires the fuller responsibility of the ruling class or the closer dependence of government upon the people.But in the later phase,when he emphasises the evils of democracy,does he not condemn what is a necessary implication in the very process which he approves?The division of labour,he now observes,narrows a man's life and interests;the necessity of co-operation narrows the sphere of 'individuality';and the process which gives diversity to society as a whole implies certain uniformities in the social atoms.The less the variety in the units,the greater is the facility of arranging them in different configurations.The eccentric man is a cross-grained piece of timber which cannot be worked into the state.

'Individuality'is so far a hindrance to the power of entering into an indefinite number of combinations.And yet so far as 'individuality'diminishes,the responsibility of government means the subordination of rulers to the average commonplace stupidity.What,then,is the 'individuality'which may be called unconditionally good?How are we to define the danger so as to avoid condemning the conformity which is a necessary implication of progress?How are we to manage 'differentiation'at the expense of 'integration';to exalt such 'individuality'as is incompatible with 'sociality';and to regard 'eccentricity'and 'antagonism'and contradiction as valuable in themselves instead of accidental results in particular cases of originality which in some sense is priceless?Here,I think,is the real difficulty.

Have we to deal with forces necessarily 'counteracting'each other,in Mill's phrase,or with forces which can be combined in a healthy organism?Mill undoubtedly supposes that some conciliation is possible.The historical view has shown the evil.

We have now to consider the remedy to be applied to the various forms in which it affects economic,political,and ethical conditions.The general principle has been given.

'Self-protection'is the only justification for the interference of society with the individual.Although absolute liberty would mean anarchy,we may still demand a maximum of liberty,and suppress such a use of liberty by one man as would in fact restrain the liberty of another.Mill,like Bentham,holds to the purely empirical view.Interference is bad when the harm caused by the coercion is not counterbalanced by the good.

Bentham's doctrine is not only plausible but,within a certain sphere,points to one of the most obvious and essential conditions of useful legislation.The Utilitarians were always affected by the legal principles from which they started.In the case of criminal law,Mill's principle marks the obvious minimum of interference.A state must suppress violence.If I claim liberty to break your head,the policeman is bound to interfere.

If you and I claim the same loaf,the state,even if it be a communistic state,must either settle which is to eat it,or leave us to fight for it.And,again,if the principle does not fix the maximum of legislation,it points to the most obvious limiting considerations.The state means the judge and the policeman,who cannot look into the heart,and must classify criminal action by its definable external characteristics.It can reach the murderer but not the malevolent man,who would murder if he could.It is therefore incompetent to punish wickedness except so far as wickedness is manifested by overt acts.If it went further it would be unjust,because acting blindly,as well as intolerably inquisitorial.Nor can it generally punish actions which produce no assignable injury to individuals.To punish a man for neglecting definite duties is necessary;but to try to punish the idleness which may have caused the neglect would be monstrous.The state would have to be omniscient and omnipresent,and at most would favour hypocrisy instead of virtue.Briefly,the law is far too coarse an instrument for the function of enforcing morality in general.It must generally confine itself to cases where injury is inflicted upon an assignable person and by conduct defined by definite outward manifestations.This had been clearly stated by Bentham.Mill,in his chapter on the 'limits of the authority of society upon the individual,'insists upon objections obvious in the legal case.Can we deduce from these legal limits a general principle defining the relation between society and its units?I notice first the difficulty already suggested by the Political Economy.

IV.ECONOMIC APPLICATION

同类推荐
  • 筠廊二笔

    筠廊二笔

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 希叟绍昙禅师语录

    希叟绍昙禅师语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 天潢玉牒

    天潢玉牒

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Chignecto Isthmus And Its First Settlers

    The Chignecto Isthmus And Its First Settlers

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 观世音菩萨得大势菩萨受记经

    观世音菩萨得大势菩萨受记经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 初冬无眠

    初冬无眠

    世界最性感的关系:男女之间的友情。屌炸天的延安暗戳戳喜欢“大学霸”戴冰,耍贱,卖萌,求关注。他身边最多的是狐朋狗友。他是老师办公室的常客。他动起手来自己都害怕。“大学霸”戴冰撇了撇嘴,以为他延安是一个不学无术,游手好闲的十块钱能找一沓的混混,后来发现年级第一的同学也叫延安,“大学霸”戴冰眯了眯眼。
  • 火影之明在我心

    火影之明在我心

    《火影忍者》的漫画早已完结,动画也接近尾声。陪伴我们多年的朋友一路走来,它留给我们的不仅仅是那一幕幕励志的画面,一幕幕令人感动的瞬间,一幕幕呼之欲出的热血。。。。。。一万个人就有一万个对火影世界的认识。虽然我是第一次这样正式地写网络小说,但我想把我的第一次写作留给火影,想将我对火影的理解和所期望的方向表现出来。这部作品我想写的朴实些,可能文笔很青涩,但是这部作品没有金手指,没有逆天改命的技能,没有多女主,也没有男同,带给读者的只有——我的火影世界。第一次写,希望不好的地方多多包涵!
  • 西游之鹏程万里

    西游之鹏程万里

    “轰隆!”一声震天巨响,赵阊(chang)的灵魂突然和一只刚出生的不明鸟类重合在了一起。而此地,叫做西牛贺洲!
  • 你有拯救情结吗

    你有拯救情结吗

    对不起,我也不知道是什么,大概就是一个有钱有颜有身材的帅哥对一个被家庭暴力以及渣男虐过满身伤痕的姑娘死缠烂打的故事。新手,有点慢热。
  • 双龙之凤

    双龙之凤

    阑漪一门心思想着赚钱带着相依为命的娘亲离开这个让自己伤痕累累的家。本想干一票大的,就足够两人下半辈子的生活所需。却不想与皇太子纠缠在一起。女扮男装却是早已被看透。两个因为不同的原因都不再相信相濡以沫的感情的两个人死死地纠缠在一起,究竟是谁看透了谁,又是谁入戏太深,最后,爱意成魔。爱至成伤。我只要你留在我的身边,无论是什么身份!!!帝王的命令不得违抗。阑漪只有一句话。轻轻地,带着反抗。你配吗?死亡是对命运的妥协,而我一辈子都在反抗,也从未想过会有一个温暖安定的未来。一无所有的人还有什么可以顾虑的,我本就什么都不曾拥有。你,不要小瞧了女孩子了。
  • 何安天下

    何安天下

    灵气反世,当安天下。皇权恶毒,当立大同。天下皆修,共入黄天。
  • 唐书志传通俗演义

    唐书志传通俗演义

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 追妻无门:女boss不好惹

    追妻无门:女boss不好惹

    青涩蜕变,如今她是能独当一面的女boss,爱了冷泽聿七年,也同样花了七年时间去忘记他。以为是陌路,他突然向他表白,扬言要娶她,她只当他是脑子抽风,他的殷勤她也全都无视。他帮她查她父母的死因,赶走身边情敌,解释当初拒绝她的告别,和故意对她冷漠都是无奈之举。突然爆出她父母的死居然和冷家有丝毫联系,还莫名跳出个公爵未婚夫,扬言要与她履行婚约。峰回路转,破镜还能重圆吗? PS:我又开新文了,每逢假期必书荒,新文《有你的世界遇到爱》,喜欢我的文的朋友可以来看看,这是重生类现言,对这个题材感兴趣的一定要收藏起来。
  • 全球史是什么

    全球史是什么

    全球史是目前历史学科里发展迅猛讨论激烈的热门领域,在历史研究领域也已成为一个富有活力和创新性的学科,它以世界整体的连贯性为出发点,有力地挑战了我们之前的史学方法。《全球史是什么》全面概述了历史学中这一令人振奋的新取径,探究了全球史学科在21世纪将要面临的某些重大问题:全球史与其他世界史诠释有何差别?我们如何摆脱欧洲中心论,却又不陷入新的中心论,进而书写一部全球史?历史学家如何比较诸多社群,并找到不同地域之间的兼容性?全球史有什么政治意涵?此书还深入浅出地探讨了这种新范式的局限乃至风险,以及全球史的受众等诸多问题。《全球史是什么》细致剖析了全球史的兴起、特质、方法论、前景及局限。作者塞巴斯蒂安·康拉德为当下全球史研究的领军人物,他认为:全球史既是一个研究对象,又是一种审视历史的独特方式;既是过程,又是视角;既是研究主题,又是方法论;全球史的核心关怀是流动、交换、各种跨越边界的事件以及大规模结构性转型和整合进程。历史学家如何经由整体地理解世界历史,为我们当今全球化的世界重绘历史学图景?本书将给出答案。
  • 星耀主神

    星耀主神

    “你们看到星空中最亮的那一颗星星了吗?”“那,就是我!”“我叫江流儿,也叫,星耀主神!”