登陆注册
5493800000011

第11章

40.If you defend Sir Isaac's notions,as delivered in his'Principia,'it must be on the rigorous foot of rejecting nothing,neither admitting nor casting away infinitely small quantities.If you defend the Marquis,whom you also style your Master,it must be on the foot of admitting that there are infinitesimals,that they may be rejected,that they are nevertheless real quantities,and themselves infinitely subdivisible.

But you seem to have grown giddy with passion,and in the heat of controversy to have mistaken and forgot your part.I beseech you,Sir,to consider that the Marquis (whom alone,and not Sir Isaac,this double error in finding the subtangent doth concern)rejects indeed infinitesimals,but not on the foot that you do,to wit,their being inconsiderable in practical geometry or mixed mathematics.But he rejects them in the accuracy of speculative knowledge:in which respect there may be great logical errors,although there should be no sensible mistake in practice;which,it seems,is what you cannot comprehend.He rejects them likewise in virtue of a postulatum,which I venture to call rejecting them without ceremony.And,though he inferreth a conclusion accurately true,yet he doth it,contrary to the rules of logic,from inaccurate and false premises.And how this comes about,I have at large explained in the'Analyst,'and shewed in that particular case of tangents,that the rejectaneous quantity might have been a finite quantity of any given magnitude,and yet the conclusion have come out exactly the same way;and,consequently,that the truth of this method doth not depend on the reason assigned by the Marquis,to wit,the postulatum for throwing away infinitesimals;and,therefore,that he and his followers acted blindfold,as not knowing the true reason for the conclusions coming out accurately right,which I shew to have been the effect of a double error.

41.This is the truth of the matter,which you shamefully misrepresent and declaim upon,to no sort of purpose but to amuse and mislead your reader.For which conduct of yours throughout your remarks,you will pardon me if I cannot otherwise account,than from a secret hope that the reader of your'Defence'would never read the'Analyst.'

If he doth,he cannot but see what an admirable method you take to defend your cause:how,instead of justifying the reasoning,the logic,or the theory of the case specified,which is the real point,you discourse of sensible and practical errors:and how all this is a manifest imposition upon the reader.He must needs see that I have expressly said,"I have no controversy except only about your logic and method:that I consider how you demonstrate;what objects you are conversant about;and whether you conceive them clearly.''That I have often expressed myself to the same effect,desiring the reader to remember,"that I am only concerned about the way of coming at your theorems,whether it be legitimate or illegitimate,clear or obscure,scientific or tentative:that I have,on this very occasion,to prevent all possibility of mistake,repeated and insisted that I consider the geometrical analyst as a logician,i.e.so far forth as he reasons and argues;and his mathematical conclusions,not in themselves but in their premises;not as true or false,useful or insignificant,but as derived from such principles,and by such inferences.''[`Analyst,'sect.20.]

You affirm (and indeed what can you not affirm?)that the difference between the true subtangent and that found without any compensation is absolutely nothing at all.I profess myself of a contrary opinion.My reason is,because nothing cannot be divided into parts.But this difference is capable of being divided into any,or into more than any given number of parts;for the truth of which consult the Marquis de l'Hospital.And,be the error in fact or in practice ever so small,it will not thence follow that the error in reasoning,which is what I am alone concerned about,is one whit the less,it being evident that a man may reason most absurdly about the minutest things.

42.Pray answer me fairly,once for all,whether it be your opinion that whatsoever is little and inconsiderable enough to be rejected without inconvenience in practice,the same may in like manner be safely rejected and overlooked in theory and demonstration.if you say No ,it will then follow that all you have been saying here and elsewhere,about yards,and inches,and decimal fractions,setting forth and insisting on the extreme smallness of the rejectaneous quantity,is quite foreign to the argument,and only a piece of skill to impose upon your reader.If you say Yes ,it follows that you then give up at once all the orders of fluxions and infinitesimal differences;and so most imprudently turn all your sallies and attacks and veterans to your own overthrow.If the reader is of my mind,he will despair of ever seeing you get clear of this dilemma.The points in controversy have been so often and so distinctly noted in the'Analyst'that I very much wonder how you could mistake,if you had no mind to mistake.It is very plain,if you are in earnest,that you neither understand me not your masters.And what shall we think of other ordinary analysts,when it shall be found that even you,who like a champion step forth to defend their principles,have not considered them?

同类推荐
  • 张果星宗

    张果星宗

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 大法炬陀罗尼经

    大法炬陀罗尼经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 妇科问答

    妇科问答

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 神仙服食灵草菖蒲丸方传

    神仙服食灵草菖蒲丸方传

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • On the Generation of Animals

    On the Generation of Animals

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 天上掉下个鬼老公

    天上掉下个鬼老公

    惊鸿一瞥的男神在她眼前死去,还缠着她不放,要她做他的老婆......呵呵,听过人鬼殊途么!男主:没听过,不管是人,是鬼,你都是我的。我:妈妈,地球好可怕啊!!!
  • 永不瞑目

    永不瞑目

    除了生命终止前的这个刹那,庆春确信自己已经了解了全部的肖童。就是对这个奇怪的刹那,她仿佛也能隐隐感知……年轻美丽的女刑警庆春与战友一起接手一桩贩毒大案,热情单纯的大学生肖童出于对欧的爱情接受了公安局派他深入毒巢刺探内幕的凶险任务……惊心动魄的缉毒大战交织着缠绵的爱情悲剧正在上演……
  • 盟主夫人不好当

    盟主夫人不好当

    张沫楚的人生中有两个男人,养父教会了她杀人,男友教会了她如何过普通人的生活,其余的一切张沫楚就像是一张白纸一般。然后,曾经是杀手的张沫楚在没有一丝防备之下就被男友推到了马路上,然后,被车撞死了。张沫楚想着男友明明说过杀人是不可以的,但是,为什么男友要杀她呢?在张沫楚思考着的时候,张沫楚就穿越了,她成了魔教少主。洞房花烛,她居然成亲了,成了万仙盟盟主的夫人。这些她都接受了!可为什么万仙盟盟主都成亲了,还有一大推的小姑娘在山庄下面喊着要和万仙盟盟主成亲啊!有情敌就算了,这个盟主大人也不是什么安分的主子!张沫楚真的很想过一天安生日子啊!这个盟主夫人太不好当了,她可以不要吗?--情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 好运又被boss作掉了

    好运又被boss作掉了

    (1V1,爽文,宠文,励志文。)惊爆!传闻H市那不近女色,高冷毒舌的矜贵阎罗王人设崩塌了!他其实是见一个爱一个还不挑食的极品渣男!一天,陆北卿接受采访,“陆总,对于爆料你怎么看?”陆北卿:“我对我的锦鲤不止专一还很深情。”记者当即拿出几张风格迥异,美丑不一的照片:“那她们,你认识吗?”陆北卿认真看了一眼,扬唇道,“都是我的心肝宝贝儿。”记者:卧槽!说好的专一深情呢?网友:渣男!不接受反驳!一见到某渣男就要倒霉,却又各种逆袭打脸绿茶白莲的夏初暖嫌弃的唾了一口:“呸!不要脸的灾星!”
  • 独裁柔少

    独裁柔少

    “权势,是男人最好的外衣!”这是少主蓝鑫伟最为热衷的一句话!身为部落大族长的儿子,他比任何人都渴望权势,渴望有一天可以统领整个位面!但是,当他面对自己心爱的女人的时候,却可以放下所有的一切!哪怕是自己的身旁美女成群,他依然可以做到弱水三千只取一瓢!哪怕是遭到家族乃至整个部落的全力反对,他也可以为了心上人,而抛弃自己所拥有的一切!
  • 思维的乐趣

    思维的乐趣

    作为一个自由人文主义者,王小波终其一生思考着并快乐着。他以自身对“文化大革命”的记忆为重要矿藏,用杂文以独有的调侃的笔调完成了对自由和理性的反思和书写。由李银河编选的王小波杂文集《思维的乐趣》展示给我们的正是一座巍然屹立于戏谑的笑容和令人会心而战栗的幽默之后的智性的迷宫,并让我们在真切地体会到思维给人带来的无与伦比的快乐的同时,从他那里学会如何去独立而自由地思考。
  • 汪汪,忠犬夫君

    汪汪,忠犬夫君

    郑七小娘子生平有三愿。一愿,爹爹平安醒来;二愿,那个害了爹爹的坏世子倒霉倒霉倒霉!三愿,给她家萌萌哒大白找个漂亮的狗媳妇!顾衍小世子生平有三愿。一愿,自己装狗不要被郑小七发现;二愿,自己装狗不要被郑小七发现;三愿,自己装狗不要被郑小七发现;如此,无限,循环……
  • 各有一界

    各有一界

    安禾总想着能四处看看,带着也许一两个,也许四五个同伴,只是有时候,总有什么东西推着她向前走,走到那个黝黑的地方去。
  • 懒做地主婆

    懒做地主婆

    清晨大早,满村满巷贴满了大字报:轩辕家公子轩辕泽远不守夫道,今日,我沐田田休之,从此,靠近我百米之内,打之;十米之内,废之;一米之内-------------.所有人的眼睛睁大,嘴角抽搐,很想知道,一米之内会怎样?她很普通,从大山里走进现代社会的女孩,有着温润帅气的未婚夫,有着疼爱自己的双亲,却在回家途中的风雨之夜,被车撞上。从此,回家,成了一个梦。灵魂穿越,她成了那个街头衣衫褴褛的小丫头。痴呆的她,抬起纯净的大眼睛,那里面滚动的是比太阳还要灼目的光芒,她,要回家。什么,什么,那个地主的儿子,竟然为了个郡主,设计陷害了自己这个身体的全家,外带着不准任何人施舍丁点的食物给他们,否则鞭刑伺候,她愤了,她怒了,她要用鞭刑伺候伺候他。娃娃亲,他不想娶,她还更不愿意嫁,不过,仇却要报。某日清晨,那张奇特舒服的床上,沐田田睁开眼睛,看见了轩辕泽远那张妖孽的脸,献媚的笑容,她一拳挥之,所有的人屏住了呼吸,等着看轩辕地主家的独子会遭遇的一切。他是杀手,终生没有自由,可是那一夜,七岁的她凭着小小的智谋救了他,从此,他是她的影子,上山种茶,下厨做饭,爱,在无声里滋长:守侯,不是为了拥有,是为了你甜美的笑容耀眼过初升的太阳,沉默,不是冷硬,是为了压制我那颗太炙热的心。他是皇子,终生为了那九五之尊,勾心斗角,却一头栽进了只有七岁女娃的小手心里,看着那白嫩的肌肤,他很想咬满牙印,辣手催花。只是最后,他的心,被摧残的满目疮痍:强掠,是我的终身信条,只是,你怎么比我还强盗?国库都在你手里三分之二了,还不给我留点吃喝嫖赌的本金吗?他是地主,一个有着天人之姿的男人,勾魂的单凤眼,薄唇染风情。他眼高于顶,却恨着那个小豆丁未婚妻,为了娶到心仪的美丽郡主,他和她斗了十年,商斗,宅斗,床斗.,最后他输的一塌糊涂:娘子,我们从小的娃娃亲,岂只是一个夫妻百日恩,你就舍得我光着身子从这里走回家吗?现代小女人沐田田,她的小手指尖挑起的不是针线女红,不是三从四德,究竟是神马?亲们还等着什么,快快点击一睹为快,她的------懒做地主婆。亲们,天空回来了,带着天空酝酿了半年的文文,希望给亲们一个不一样的精彩故事。推荐精彩文文:《拍卖兽性殿下》友文连接:《媚婚》妩媚重生《极恶嫡妇》无计春留住《魔尊媚世》安甜妮哥《调教宠物》安甜妮哥《第一寡妇》狐少《丑颜倾国》紫婉儿
  • 将女惊华:将军大人太霸道

    将女惊华:将军大人太霸道

    国公府的嫡女,嫁与将军为妻,助他成为一代名将,却被夫君婆婆厌弃,怀孕之时,他宠爱小妾,以克星为由剖腹夺子,更拿她顶罪屠之。杀身之仇,涅槃重生,她杀心机姐妹,诛恶毒继母,夺回母亲嫁妆,渣男和小妾都一一死在她的剑下。重活一世,她不再痴恋,可偏遇那不讲道理的霸道元帅。“我这个所谓国公府嫡女说白了只是个乡野丫头,配不起元帅,不嫁!”“嫡女也好,乡野丫头也好,本帅娶定了!”“我心肠歹毒,容不得你三妻四妾,元帅若不想后院血流成河,最好别招惹我。”