"So at least"--Mrs.Dyott a little corrected herself--"one has gathered (for I don't read your books, you know!) that they're usually shown as doing."Maud wondered, but looking at Voyt, "They're shown often, no doubt, as paying for their badness.But are they shown as paying for their romance?""My dear lady," said Voyt, "their romance is their badness.There isn't any other.It's a hard law, if you will, and a strange, but goodness has to go without that luxury.Isn't to BE good just exactly, all round, to go without?" He put it before her kindly and clearly--regretfully too, as if he were sorry the truth should be so sad.He and she, his pleasant eyes seemed to say, would, had they had the making of it, have made it better."One has heard it before--at least I have; one has heard your question put.But always, when put to a mind not merely muddled, for an inevitable answer.'Why don't you, cher monsieur, give us the drama of virtue?' 'Because, chere madame, the high privilege of virtue is precisely to avoid drama.' The adventures of the honest lady? The honest lady hasn't, can't possibly have, adventures."Mrs.Blessingbourne only met his eyes at first, smiling with some intensity."Doesn't it depend a little on what you call adventures?""My poor Maud," said Mrs.Dyott as if in compassion for sophistry so simple, "adventures are just adventures.That's all you can make of them!"But her friend talked for their companion and as if without hearing."Doesn't it depend a good deal on what you call drama?"Maud spoke as one who had already thought it out."Doesn't it depend on what you call romance?"Her listener gave these arguments his very best attention."Of course you may call things anything you like--speak of them as one thing and mean quite another.But why should it depend on anything? Behind these words we use--the adventure, the novel, the drama, the romance, the situation, in short, as we most comprehensively say--behind them all stands the same sharp fact which they all in their different ways represent.""Precisely!" Mrs.Dyott was full of approval.
Maud however was full of vagueness."What great fact?""The fact of a relation.The adventure's a relation; the relation's an adventure.The romance, the novel, the drama are the picture of one.The subject the novelist treats is the rise, the formation, the development, the climax and for the most part the decline of one.And what is the honest lady doing on that side of the town?"Mrs.Dyott was more pointed."She doesn't so much as FORM a relation."But Maud bore up."Doesn't it depend again on what you call a relation?""Oh," said Mrs.Dyott, "if a gentleman picks up her pocket-handkerchief--"
"Ah even that's one," their friend laughed, "if she has thrown it to him.We can only deal with one that is one.""Surely," Maud replied."But if it's an innocent one--""Doesn't it depend a good deal," Mrs.Dyott asked, "on what you call innocent?""You mean that the adventures of innocence have so often been the material of fiction? Yes," Voyt replied; "that's exactly what the bored reader complains of.He has asked for bread and been given a stone.What is it but, with absolute directness, a question of interest or, as people say, of the story? What's a situation undeveloped but a subject lost? If a relation stops, where's the story? If it doesn't stop, where's the innocence? It seems to me you must choose.It would be very pretty if it were otherwise, but that's how we flounder.Art is our flounderings shown."Mrs.Blessingbourne--and with an air of deference scarce supported perhaps by its sketchiness--kept her deep eyes on this definition.
"But sometimes we flounder out."
It immediately touched in Colonel Voyt the spring of a genial derision."That's just where I expected YOU would! One always sees it come.""He has, you notice," Mrs.Dyott parenthesised to Maud, "seen it come so often I; and he has always waited for it and met it.""Met it, dear lady, simply enough! It's the old story, Mrs.
Blessingbourne.The relation's innocent that the heroine gets out of.The book's innocent that's the story of her getting out.But what the devil--in the name of innocence--was she doing IN?"Mrs.Dyott promptly echoed the question."You have to be in, you know, to GET out.So there you are already with your relation.
It's the end of your goodness."
"And the beginning," said Voyt, "of your play!""Aren't they all, for that matter, even the worst," Mrs.Dyott pursued, "supposed SOME time or other to get out? But if meanwhile they've been in, however briefly, long enough to adorn a tale?""They've been in long enough to point a moral.That is to point ours!" With which, and as if a sudden flush of warmer light had moved him, Colonel Voyt got up.The veil of the storm had parted over a great red sunset.
Mrs.Dyott also was on her feet, and they stood before his charming antagonist, who, with eyes lowered and a somewhat fixed smile, had not moved.
"We've spoiled her subject!" the elder lady sighed.
"Well," said Voyt, "it's better to spoil an artist's subject than to spoil his reputation.I mean," he explained to Maud with his indulgent manner, "his appearance of knowing what he has got hold of, for that, in the last resort, is his happiness."She slowly rose at this, facing him with an aspect as handsomely mild as his own."You can't spoil my happiness."He held her hand an instant as he took leave."I wish I could add to it!"
