登陆注册
5416500000118

第118章 Chapter V(3)

Austin was clearly right in pointing out the difference;and scientific thinkers,before and since his time,have had to struggle with a fallacy,singularly tenacious of life.A 'law of nature'in the scientific sense is not a law in the jurist's sense.The difference may be regarded in another way The two senses of law differ as a 'command'differs from a proposition;the imperative from the indicative mood.The command,'Do not murder,'is not a simple proposition.It belongs rather to action than to belief.It utters a volition and therefore creates a fact,instead of simply expressing a truth.Yet a command is also a fact,and may be regarded as part of the general system of fact.The command,'Do not murder,'implies the fact,'murder is forbidden.'We might show that in certain social conditions murder becomes punishable by death.That is a property of society at certain stages.If the social machinery worked with perfect accuracy,it would be as much a law of nature that a society kills murderers as that a wolf kills lambs or that fire burns straw.From this point of view,then,a 'law proper'falls under the conception of a 'law of nature,'though a law of nature is not a 'law proper.'It is a law of nature in the making,or a law of nature which is only fulfilled when a number of complex conditions of human conduct are satisfied.Austin,denying that free-will means a really arbitrary element,would no doubt have admitted that the 'law proper'was a product of the general laws (in the scientific sense)of human nature.This aspect of the case,however,passes out of sight.The law is something created;'set,'as he calls it,or laid down by the sovereign at his own will,and is thus perfectly arbitrary.That is the ultimate fact,and makes a radical difference.We stop at the 'command,'and do not ask how the command itself comes into existence.This corresponds to J.S.Mill's distinction between 'making'and 'growing.'Law belongs to the region of 'making.'It originates in the will of the sovereign.Whatever he wills and 'sanctions,'and nothing else,is therefore law in the proper sense of the term.

Another class of 'laws'is excluded by the definition.A'custom'is not a law proper.I obey many rules,which are not 'commands'and not enforced by legal sanctions.I conform to countless rules of conduct,though no assignable person has ever made them,and though the sovereign will not punish me for breaking them.In such rules the disapproval of society may act in the same way as a sanction,though not annexed by a sovereign.

The resemblance may pass into identity.Customs become laws,as they receive the sanction of the legislator or of the courts.

This includes Bentham's 'judge-made'law;and Austin diverges from Bentham by recognising this as a legitimate mode of legislation.The question then arises whether the distinction between laws and customs is essential or superficial --a real distinction of kinds or only important in our classification.

From the lawyer's point of view,again,the importance is obvious.He always wishes to know precisely at what point the law can be brought to bear.whether a rule will be enforced by the courts,or generally Under what circumstances a custom will be accepted as a law.The answer necessarily leads to much legal subtlety.The custom may be treated as constructively a law.The sovereign has not actually made nor 'sanctioned'it;but virtue has somehow gone out of him by implication,and his recognition is equivalent to imposition of the rule.Though the 'sovereign'has not really 'made'the law,he may be considered as having made it by a metaphysical fiction.In this direction Austin becomes the twelfth century schoolman,and has to split hairs to force his definition upon the facts.The inquiry,though necessary from the lawyer's point of view,becomes irrelevant from the sociologist's.The social action is the same,whether the rule obeyed be a custom or a law strictly so called.

Confusion therefore follows when the question of legal validity is substituted for the question of real efficacy.Primitive societies obey implicitly a variety of elaborate 'laws'or 'customs,'though they have no conception of legislation.The obedience to the rule is instinctive,and the rule regarded as absolutely unalterable.Are such rules 'laws'--though not made by a sovereign --or mere 'customs,'though obeyed as strictly as the most effective 'laws'?Austin answers consistently that they are not laws at all.There are people,he says,in 'a state of nature,'(4)such as the savages in New Holland or North America.

同类推荐
  • 阿弥陀经通赞疏

    阿弥陀经通赞疏

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 金人铭

    金人铭

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 六十种曲浣纱记

    六十种曲浣纱记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 旗军志

    旗军志

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 伤寒捷诀

    伤寒捷诀

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 渡佛成魔

    渡佛成魔

    她和他注定是别离,在她看来,他的三世劫难,是对她的恩赐。就算,灰飞烟灭的是她,成佛的是他。
  • 火夫人

    火夫人

    魂穿乱世,她保有前世的惊世才华。在现代她能打造一个庞大的商业帝国,在古代同样能素手掀波浪!可她偏却遇上一群难以摆脱的男子。银发红眸的他,一脸杀气道:“你必须跟本王走,你没得选择。”温文尔雅的他,永远挂着招牌式的微笑道:“寡人如此真心待你,你却弃如敝履。你要如何才肯留在寡人身边?”邪魅的他,一脸媚笑道:“只要你告诉本相长寿的秘诀,本相就放了你。”怒火卷月,她所到之处,寸草不留。火夫人之名,传遍四国,扬名十洲大地。欲火凤凰,展翅高飞。风云卷月,血洗大地。日月凌空,傲视天下。给点预告:第二卷《红颜一怒争天下》青桑莞尔一笑:“夏红莲,我不需要选择,因为我早就决定好了。”“刘骜你的真心有多少?可以拿天下来换我的真心吗?”青桑冷漠的回言,那绝美的容颜上却带着桃花一般的笑容。“花凤梧你的想要长寿的秘诀吗?我告诉你,你听好了。”青桑故作一脸严肃,轻轻嗓子,轻吟道:“那就是保持呼吸,永远不要断气。”第三卷《凤魂易主天下乱》她改头换面,重新回来,看着他对她如此陌生的眼神,她莞尔一笑,学着他的摸样,说道:“桑儿,三年以后,朕一定带着你,踏遍这山山水水,揽天下与你一起入怀,站在泰山之巅笑看这飘渺世间。他瞬间惊愕,原来这个才是她的桑儿。她再次救他,望着他复杂又熟悉的脸,她笑道:“如果因为不是生在同一个世间,而让我无法遇到你。那么我情愿选择生在同一个世间与他对峙争天下。”他愕然,浅浅一笑,原来她才是那个让他魂牵梦绕的女子。她又一次遇上他,睨着他对她垂涎三尺,她邪笑道:“阵阵清风拂绿荫,幽幽清香沁人心。不记烦恼心悠然,快乐一时是一时。”说罢,抬手为他宽衣解带。他羞愤的退后三尺,大笑道:“女人,你回来了!”第四卷《携手美人定江山》雪藏很纠结,决定最后一卷的预告保密,大家书里看吧!推荐亲亲转身师傅和桂圆师傅的文转身《神笑》转身《六宫无妃》天下归元《扶摇皇后》天下归元《帝凰》推荐好友文潇湘冬儿《妖红》北棠《涅槃》端夜楠《异世御神》落随心《枭女》古幸玲《爱上离婚的女人》姜黎《惹上魔皇叔》月下波笔《红楼梦之禛点黛》:红传说《王的俘虏》领养开始了,喜欢谁就领回家养着,喜欢就要下手快,看留言先后为准!
  • 土地婆婆升职记

    土地婆婆升职记

    木小唯本来只是想某一条出路,哪知道被人针对,一不小心就卷入了新一轮的仙妖大战,明明她只是一个小角色,最后却非让她变成了神来之笔,嗷~
  • 圣观自在菩萨不空王秘密心陀罗尼经

    圣观自在菩萨不空王秘密心陀罗尼经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 女先生

    女先生

    沈初云是大宅门里的长媳,她加入女权队伍,成为北洋时期女学生心目中的偶像。可她却是人前风光人后心酸,丈夫纨绔公婆严苛爹娘守旧。当婚姻索然无味,她一纸诉状提出离婚,婆家以不变应万变,娘家怒然与之断绝关系。她痛哭过但没有倒下去,她要以笔写心,她告诉世人,人人平等当从男女平等起!
  • 异世界精灵物语

    异世界精灵物语

    作为一个高贵的生命,骄傲的生活于秘林之中。不胆怯,因为生于秘林当归于秘林。不莽撞,因为需谨记先祖训言。对外来的污秽之物给予严惩。将不尊祖训之族火祭于先灵。时刻铭记当守之道。勿要背离荣耀之路。绝望中当怀希望。荣华中不略隐患之灾。以此。以着骄傲而不骄纵的姿态,作为高贵而伟大的物种而活。——精灵族祖训,发现于一颗千年古树上
  • 倾世狂妃有点甜

    倾世狂妃有点甜

    “白煜承,你可冷?”“嗯?”“我的意思是说,你冷吗?需要把被子捂暖和吗?”“不需要”“怎么能不需要呢?你看外面月黑风高,那风一吹过来,冷得就像刀刮一样”“入夏了,不冷”“那我冷,我很冷”“那便加被子”“被子哪有你抱着缓和啊!”“嗯?”“白煜承,我陪你睡怎么样?这样我就不冷了”“不可”“有何不可?”“你我既不是夫妻,便没有男女同寝的道理”“什么道理,亲都亲过了还在乎不是夫妻吗?”……对于这一点,堂堂九幽王也很是无奈,没办法,只能放任。意外带回来的小丫头每天的事情除了抱他便是缠着他,还是一样的,他只能惯着。
  • 道士和鬼鬼

    道士和鬼鬼

    道士和鬼鬼的捉鬼日常,搞笑中不失温暖,虐心后又充满温情。苦情人,何苦情。
  • 至尊卡牌屋

    至尊卡牌屋

    五好青年来到新的世界,还好获得了神奇的卡牌屋系统。魔法师的速行咒不会,来个一星卡自行车?三只地狱猎鹰打不过,五星卡召唤武装直升机!哪个刺客要来gank我?六星卡360°绝对防御!看异类魔法师在异界叱咤风云,逍遥快活。
  • 追妻无门:女boss不好惹

    追妻无门:女boss不好惹

    青涩蜕变,如今她是能独当一面的女boss,爱了冷泽聿七年,也同样花了七年时间去忘记他。以为是陌路,他突然向他表白,扬言要娶她,她只当他是脑子抽风,他的殷勤她也全都无视。他帮她查她父母的死因,赶走身边情敌,解释当初拒绝她的告别,和故意对她冷漠都是无奈之举。突然爆出她父母的死居然和冷家有丝毫联系,还莫名跳出个公爵未婚夫,扬言要与她履行婚约。峰回路转,破镜还能重圆吗? PS:我又开新文了,每逢假期必书荒,新文《有你的世界遇到爱》,喜欢我的文的朋友可以来看看,这是重生类现言,对这个题材感兴趣的一定要收藏起来。