登陆注册
5650300000054

第54章

According to Adam Smith, there was again some truth in each of these theories, but they each fell short of that completeness of explanation which was the merit of his own peculiar system.

The self-love theory, best expounded by Hobbes and Mandeville, reduced the principle of approbation to a remote perception of the tendency of conduct upon personal well-being; and the merit of virtue or demerit of vice consisted in their respectively serving to support or disturb society, the preservation of which was so necessary to the security of individual existence.

To this our author objects, that this perception of the good effects of virtue enhances indeed our appreciation of it, but that it does not cause it. When the innumerable advantages of a cultivated and social life over a savage and solitary one are described, and the necessity of virtue pointed out for the maintenance of the one, and the tendency of vice to reproduce the other, the reader is charmed with the novelty of the observation;"he sees plainly a new beauty in virtue and a new deformity in vice, which he had never taken notice of before; and is commonly so delighted with the discovery, that he seldom takes time to reflect that this political view, having never occurred to him in his life before, cannot possibly be the ground of that approbation and disapprobation with which he has always been accustomed to consider those different qualities."In the application of the self-love theory to our praise or blame of actions or conduct in past timeas of the virtue of Cato or of the villany of Catilinethere was only an imaginary, not an actual, reference to self;and in praising or blaming in such cases we thought of what might have happened to us, had we lived in those times, or of what might still happen to us if in our own times we met with such characters. The idea which the authors of this theory "were groping about, but which they were never able to unfold distinctly, was that indirect sympathy which we feel with the gratitude or resentment of those who received the benefit or suffered the damage resulting from such opposite characters."Is the principle of sympathy then a selfish principle? Is sympathy with the sorrow or indignation of another an emotion founded on self-love, because it arises from bringing the case of another home to oneself; and then conceiving of one's own feelings in the same situation?

The answer to this question is important, and is best giver in Adam Smith's own words, as he himself admits that the whole account of human nature which deduces all sentiments and affections from self-love, seems to have arisen "from some confused misapprehension of the system of sympathy."His answer, which is as follows, will perhaps not be thought completely satisfactory : "Though sympathy is very properly said to arise from an imaginary change of situations with the person principally concerned, yet this imaginary change is not supposed to happen to me in my own person and character, but in that of the person with whom I sympathize. When Icondole with you for the loss of your only son, in order to enter into your grief I do not consider what I, a person of such a character and profession, should suffer if I had a son, and if that son was unfortunately to die;but I consider what I should suffer if I was really you; and I not only change circumstances with you, but I change persons and characters. My grief; therefore, is entirely upon your account, and not in the least upon my own. It is not, therefore, in the least selfish. How can that be regarded as a selfish passion, which does not arise even from the imagination of anything that has befallen, or that relates to myself; in my own proper person or character, but is entirely occupied about what relates to you?"Yet if a reference to self be the fundamental fact of sympathy, it would seem that this is equivalent to making a reference to self the foundation of all moral sentiment; as in Hobbes' explanation of pity, that it is grief for the calamity of another, arising from the imagination of the like calamity befalling oneself. And it is remarkable that the same passage of Polybius which has been thought to be an anticipation of the theory of sympathy, should have also been quoted by flume, as showing that Polybius referred all our sentiments of virtue to a selfish origin.

Next to the theory which founded moral approbation in self- love, comes that which founded it in reason. This theory originated in the opposition to the doctrine of Hobbes, who made the laws of the civil magistrate the sole ultimate standards of just and unjust, of right and wrongimplying the consequence, that there was no natural distinction between right and wrong, but that they were the arbitrary creations of law. Cudworth taught, that, antecedent to all law or positive institution, there was a faculty of the mind which distinguished moral qualities in actions and affections, and that this faculty was reason; the same faculty that distinguished truth from falsehood, thus also distinguishing right from wrong. It became therefore the popular doctrine, when the controversy with Hobbes was at its height, that the essence of virtue and vice did not consist in the conformity or nonconformity of actions with the law of a superior, but in their conformity or nonconformity with reason; and reason thus came to be considered as the original source of all moral approbation.

同类推荐
  • The Dragon and The Raven

    The Dragon and The Raven

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Book of Pirates

    Book of Pirates

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 四家语录

    四家语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 明伦汇编官常典宗人府部

    明伦汇编官常典宗人府部

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Pioneers of the Old South

    Pioneers of the Old South

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 七里樱

    七里樱

    年少时,我们,似乎成为了世界的主角,遗憾过,苦恼过,伤心心过,但庆幸的是在那个即将逝去的青春里,你世界的男主随着四季辗转在你身旁,陪你笑,陪你哭……终有一天,你发现他只是喜欢你身边的那个人而已…“你知道的,我喜欢她哎。”“没事…”至少我的青春,你来过就好。
  • 婚礼教堂

    婚礼教堂

    贝拉·约翰逊长期在拉斯维加斯的自家婚礼教堂为别人操办婚礼,便以为自己非常了解婚姻。未料有一天一觉醒来,发现自己竟与一位相识才一天的英国帅哥同床共枕,而这位帅哥声称他俩已经结婚。两人都不记得有过牧师主持的婚礼仪式,但各自的祖父母却一口咬定两人已成为合法夫妻……这究竟是怎么回事呢?请随男女主人公一起查明真相,来一场短小精致、轻松诙谐、启迪心灵的浪漫之旅吧!
  • 别说你会刷朋友圈 微信营销这件小事

    别说你会刷朋友圈 微信营销这件小事

    在移动互联网冲击各行业的大背景下,微信如同黑马一般闯入了社会化媒体营销的大营,备受关注。微信超大的用户群体以及超高的用户粘性使其具有非凡的营销潜力,其平台功能的不断增加也可以承载愈加丰富的营销形式。《别说你会刷朋友圈 微信营销这件小事》就是网络营销专家曹斯明讲解如何利用新媒体、新平台,在O2O时代产生最大的营销效果,致胜“微营销”。书本书是最新版本的微信营销攻略,作者凭借多年营销经验以及微信营销开荒者的阅历,通过微信实用指南与热门案例权威讲解,以及独家操作技巧向读者讲解微信营销的道与术。为那一场,数字营销的狼烟逐鹿。数字营销的方法论进化历程,永远和互联网产品密不可分,每每有跨时代的互联网产品横空出世,也同步暗示着可以被颠覆与可以被重新书写的史诗卷轴的延展而在微信逐步走向世人的岁月。
  • 乐夜

    乐夜

    由樂生夜,鬼魅无影,只手遮天,耀尘天运降,世局变
  • 弱水三千化情河

    弱水三千化情河

    声明:这是一篇女强文,女主升级是主线。甜蜜男主一直都是她最强大的后盾。情感只是辅线,尝试文。 她是将军,睥睨千军万马。她是女王,天下运筹帷幄。她却从未想过,会成为他的公主。被宠的忘乎所以。纵然另一个世界里被他出卖,但是这样的甜试问谁能抗拒。好吧,这一生,我不要江山,不要威严。就要一直一直窝在你怀里。
  • 魔女戏古代

    魔女戏古代

    推荐新文《待休王妃》收藏,支持哦!谢谢!【女强+特工】她,国家代号007的特工,身手矫健,机智慧黠,堪称高手。一次任务,她与死党双双遇难,再次睁眼时却成了男人眼中标准的胸大无脑,绝美得只能当作花瓶的草包。他,皇朝的三王爷,妖孽一般的男子,冷绝无情,严酷嗜血,在这片龙州大陆上少有人比。传言他不理国事,时常弥留烟花场所,对谁都不屑一顾。当冰冷无情的特工碰到阴沉狠辣的王爷,会发生怎样惊人的矛盾?“本王要休了你。”面对强迫促成的婚姻,他狠目相对,语声凌厉。“无所谓,反正我也不喜欢你。”柳眉一挑,她唇齿轻开,薄凉如风,清淡如水。然而,游戏一般的婚姻解除后,失落的是谁的心?痛的又是谁的心?边疆乱,烽烟起,群兽出,红颜飘零,这天下谁主沉浮?XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX本文前六十九万为公众章节,所以点进来的亲可以放心观看!多谢支持!文中女主腹黑,聪明,睿智,越来越强;文中美男多多,过程绝对精彩哦!结局嘛暂时保密\(^o^)/~无极门东山再起,掀起一系列血雨腥风,这是策划已久的阴谋,还是兴之所至?当仇恨的火焰燃到高峰时,一个灵性、顽皮、慧黠而绝世的女子,穿越到了这里。失误使她丢失时光机,命运从此改写。此女集其邪魅于一身,在这乱世中,以一张三寸不烂之舌耍的众人团团转。身怀嫁衣神功,命中注定她与无极门有缘,但她的到来是带领无极门继续复仇,还是化解这段恩怨,亦是未知。快意江湖,恩怨情仇,爱的天翻地覆,痛的刻骨铭心,闹的手脚抽筋,口吐白沫……“你,不准喜欢我。”这话霸道的从她口中冒出。“你,从今以后,全部属于我的了。”某男盯着她,掷地有声。自此,结下了千年不解的缘。可最终能与她结为连理的是龙,虓,还是虎?而她又该何去何从呢?■■■■■下面是几则片段:1.“啊——”一声惊天霹雳的大叫,“敢毁我清白?”“你终于活过来了,终于活过来了……”老天,误会大了,她不过是在给他人工呼吸啊!为了爱的人的幸福,雷鸣突然拉过神情凄凉的艾文,认真地看着她,看得深情,“嫁给我吧……”这话没有任何预兆地从他口中迸出。2.
  • 爱之夏纪

    爱之夏纪

    馨恋和夏昱恒的手紧紧地牵在了一起。这是克拉在人间的心愿,他们一定会帮克拉实现的!馨恋笑着,无比的开心,不仅仅是因为痊愈的脚伤,更是因为这个永远永远留在她心底的恶魔。还有,身旁的夏昱恒……这格外温馨的一幕,惹得病床里所有人,会心地相顾而笑。幸福,在狭小的病房里弥漫开,久久不散……
  • 木叶之超神日向

    木叶之超神日向

    隼人穿越成为日向族人,努力修行十几年,没想到系统突然降临,幸福来得太突然。线线果实还是转生眼?当然是全部都要!这是一个穿越成为日向分家,一步一步成长的脑洞故事。【Q群】588587160
  • 烟水阔,花如是

    烟水阔,花如是

    民国十年,一段痴缠纠葛的凄美爱情正在上演。一个在民国中飘零的柔弱女子,从最普通的小丫鬟成长为一位果敢的地下革命党;一个是从小不知忧愁为何物的富家少爷,后来发展民族工业,在商战中摸爬滚打,投身革命,成长为独当一面的男子汉。经历了民国的起起伏伏和战火的洗礼,曾经的一切都已覆灭,唯有不灭的是心中那团爱的火焰。
  • 中华青少年成长必读集萃:智慧背囊

    中华青少年成长必读集萃:智慧背囊

    诗人说:一花一世界。佛家讲:一叶一菩提。一则小故事蕴涵着深刻的道理,一段小经历浓缩了生命的真谛。“智慧背囊”,盛满的是人生的智慧,作文素材的宝藏。走进“智慧背囊”,走进智慧的闪亮,走进心灵的清香。一本以故事来诠释人生、社会、成败、亲情、财富、心灵、幸福等主题的书,短小精悍,滴水藏海,将许多人生哲理以最简单、最质朴的方式呈现给读者,直抵心灵,开启智慧。开启少年神奇的想象力,帮助他们树立朴素的道德观。